The prices below are the base prices for a 4-5” tall cake and a simple buttercream frosting. Additional charges are dependent on cake design, hours of work, specialty ingredients, supplies, structural support systems, toppers, fondant work, fillings etc. Dairy-free and egg-free are subject to an additional cost.
We do not currently offer vegan or gluten-free baked goods.
Any custom cake design, regardless of servings, will have a $100 order minimum. The smallest single tier cake available for customization is 6". Flavors and fillings are listed below.
Special note regarding SMASH cakes: smash cakes ordered individually apply to the $100 order minimum. We understand in most instances this is not the most ideal cost for a small cake that is more about tradition. Clients who are ordering a custom cake can add a separate smash cake on to their order for an additional cost that will be dependent on size, design, complexity and any dietary restrictions.
4" Round - serves 4-6 - $45 *not available for individual purchase, only for tiered cake options
5" Round - serves 6-8 - $60 *not available for individual purchase, only for tiered cake options
6” Round – serves 9-12 - $75
7" Round - serves 12-16 - $95
8” Round – serves 20-24 - $120
9" Round - serves 24-32 - $160
10” Round – serves 28-38 - $190
11" Round - serve 30-46 - $230
12” Round – serves 40-56 - $280
NOTE: Pricing for 3D/sculpted cakes, regardless of servings, start at a minimum of $200. Additional charges will apply depending on the extensive labor required to create. Please contact us to discuss the details and for a quote.
Cake Tasting Boxes: $65
Tasting boxes are the perfect way for couples to try different cake and filling combos for your upcoming event in the comfort of your own home! Boxes are available for large custom cake orders ($400 and up) only and are not available for individual purchase. Each box comes beautifully packaged with 3 cake flavor choices (two slices of each flavor - one for each taster), 3 filling choices and 3 frosting choices. Additional cake choices can be added at $15 per flavor and $5 per filling/frosting. Plates, utensils, tasting menu and note cards included in each box. $30 will be applied to any order of $400 or more that results in a booking within 15 days of the tasting. Tasting boxes must be requested with at least 2 weeks notice and at least 30 days prior to your event. Special dietary requests for tasting boxes are subject to an additional $15 and is not deducted from the future booking.
Below are our signature cakes. Aside from flavor and color direction, any customizations or modifications are an additional charge - including names, toppers, banners or other elements.
Classic Drip Cake: 6" $90 / 7" $110 / 8" $135 / 9" $170 / 10" $205
Any flavor cake and filling (premium fillings will be an extra charge), covered in any flavor buttercream with a ganache drip, swirls of buttercream on top and sprinkles around the bottom. Gold or Silver drip extra. Color scheme direction provided by the client.
Fresh Florals Cake: 6" $105 / 7" $125 / 8" $155 / 9" $195 / 10" $235
Any flavor cake and filling (premium fillings will be an extra charge), covered in any flavor buttercream with fresh florals. Color scheme direction provided by the client, floral selection at the discretion of Simply Sweet Brooklyn.
White (contains almond extract)
Rainbow Vanilla (subject to additional fee - not available for cake pops)
Cookies & Cream
+Denotes popular/frequently ordered flavors
Pistachio Mousse (contains pistachio nuts which are botanically considered seeds, not nuts, similar to cashews)
Lemon Pastry Jam
White Chocolate Ganache
Any flavor buttercream listed ->
Premium Fillings: (subject to additional $5-$15 fee depending on cake size)
Strawberries and Cream
Fresh Fruit (strawberries, blueberries, raspberries)
Dulce de Leche
Nutella (contains hazelnuts)